In a lifelong experience of following politics I have, until now,
never witnessed children being horse traded, and senators being
blackmailed, for the passing of legislation. In this case to reintroduce
Temporary Protection Visas.
It looks as though Immigration Minister Scott Morrison (and the senators) have taken the yes side on the ageless Christian ethical dilemma “Does the end justify the means”.
It is a fascination to me as to why people assume that religion has
some form of monopoly on morality. And even worse, they pretend to speak
on Gods behalf in dispensing it.
“I will not take moral lectures from Bill Shorten or
Sarah Hanson-Young when it comes to border protection on that or any
“So this is a win for Australia, it’s also a win for humanitarian values, it’s a win for human decency’’
“Do unto others as you would have them do unto you”
We are all wired for decency and conscience with or without religion.
Some understand it better than others illustrated by either what we do
or don’t do. By our mercy and compassion or deficiency in it.
Morrison like many of the Cabinet are serious practicing Christians
who interpret God’s word to fit snugly with their political ideology.
They easily accommodate policy with their own definition of scripture,
justifying their immorality to themselves. An evil in itself.
As someone who spent many years in a church environment similar to
Morrison s (now an open-minded atheist) I can assure the reader that
there are many who think like Morrison. They worship their politics and
religion without demarcation. In doing so they believe that telling the
truth isn’t necessarily in their best interests.
This government seems intent on imposing its own particular form of
Christianity on an unsuspecting population. And I might add, one that is
completely at odds with current Papal uttering on social inequality.
The decision to sack highly credentialed social workers, doing
excellent work in high schools and replace them with accredited
Chaplains is outrageous.
And now it seems that taxpayer funds are to be used to fund the training of Priests in religious institutions.
What ever happened to the secular society?
The fools that frequent the senate.
The inexperienced cross-bench senators buckled into the ransom
dangled before their collective conscience and awarded the executive the
power to ‘’play God ‘’ with the lives of those seeking safety from this
supposed Christian nation.
In all fairness it could not have been an easy decision.
Senator Muir, said he was:
“Forced into a corner to decide between a bad decision and a worse decision, a position I do not wish on my worst enemies”.
Maybe the Palmer United Party senators felt the same.
It has also been reported that Morrison’s department had children on
Christmas Island phone Muir and beg their freedom even giving them the
phones to do so. Now that’s something straight out of the “classic
hostage situation” handbook. That’s what terrorists do with hostages.
So, with the passing of this Bill what have we ended up with?
Crikey put it this way, calling it an immoral disgrace:
“At 8.06 this morning it was done: the House of Representatives
passed the government’s Migration and Maritime Powers Legislation
Amendment (Resolving the Asylum Legacy Caseload) Bill 2014, following
its passage and amendment just after midnight in the Senate.
Parliamentarians then got to go home for Christmas, having delivered the
Immigration Minister extraordinary powers that in effect obliterate any
further pretence that Australia regards asylum seekers as human beings.
The bill restored the failed Howard-era policy of temporary
protection visas, a mechanism that actually increased boat arrivals when
last attempted. Whether Clive Palmer seriously believes that there is a
pathway to citizenship contained in a kind of homeopathic form within
the legislation — or it merely suits its purposes to pretend there is —
we don’t know, but Scott Morrison has been crystal clear that TPVs will
never provide permanent protection.
But the bill goes much further, freeing Australia from any
obligations associated with the Refugee Convention, including giving
Morrison and his department — which has repeatedly demonstrated it is
profoundly incompetent and resistant to the most basic forms of
accountability — the power to return people to torture and persecution
without judicial review.”
On the one hand cross bench senators like Ricky Muir, Nick Xenophon
might argue that the end does indeed justify the means. After all there
will be many freed from their dreadful incarceration and the migrant
intake has been increased. But did they consider that Morrison already
held powers to resolve these issues, to release people. Especially
children. His threat was that unless they passed his legislation they
could rot in hell.
They could have called his bluff.
Their pretentious anguish at having to deal with such a choice can’t hide the grim reality of their actions.
Greg Barnes (a spokesman for the Australian Lawyers Alliance and barrister) put this way:
“But in passing this legislation Senator Muir and his colleagues
have done what many would think is unconscionable in a society that
supposedly subscribes to the rule of law – allow the executive to “play
God” with the lives of those in our world who want to put their case for
asylum to a rich, developed world country with ample capacity to take
Morrison is now effectively above the High Court and our conformity
to the International Convention on Refugees has been written out of our
The bill, in all probability is the most immoral ever passed by an Australian Parliament.
Not only that, it is also bad policy. It says much about the leaders
of this country and their shameful misrepresentation of the faith they
profess to follow.
No matter in what sphere of government policy (immigration, health,
pensioners, education etc) one looks, you find the hand of Abbott’s hate
on those who refuse to join Team Australia.
He seeks to reward those who follow and punish those who don’t. In
the past week much has been written about the horrendous failings of his
A lot has centered on Abbott’s credentials as a leader. Therein lies
the fundamental problem. For those of us who have followed his career
closely, it’s easy. He has none.
“When a stranger sojourns with you in your land, you shall not do him
wrong. You shall treat the stranger who sojourns with you as the native
among you, and you shall love him as yourself, for you were strangers in
the land of Egypt: I am the Lord your God.